Letter to the Hon. Michael E. Horowitz, Inspector General of the Department of Justice - Calling for IG Investigation into DoJ's Decision Not to Investigate Michigan Nursing Home Deaths

Letter

Dear Inspector General Horowitz,

We write to you today concerning the Department of Justice's recent decision to not investigate the State of Michigan's handling of the COVID-19 pandemic, and Governor Gretchen Whitmer's decision to place patients infected with COVID-19 into long-term care facilities. As we have learned over time, the elderly are the most vulnerable to COVID-19.

In August of 2020, the U.S. Department of Justice requested data[1] from Governor Whitmer and three other states concerning nursing homes and COVID-19 deaths. The department was concerned that these governors had "issued orders which may have resulted in the deaths of thousands of elderly nursing home residents."[2] As of July 21st, 2021, there have been 5,681 deaths in Michigan long-term care facilities.[3]

On July 22nd, 2021, it was reported that DOJ official, Steven Rosenbaum, sent a letter to Governor Whitmer's Chief of Staff, Mark Totten, informing him of the Department's decision to forgo an investigation into the governor's coronavirus decisions.[4]

This decision has thousands of Michiganders across the state concerned. Families all across the state are demanding answers for why their loved ones were locked in facilities with Covid-carrying individuals. For over a year, Michiganders have demanded answers from their governor to no avail. Last year, it seemed that the Department of Justice was going to finally get answers, from Governor Whitmer for the people of Michigan. On July 22nd, 2021, that hope faded with the Department's decision.

For that reason, we are requesting that you open a formal inquiry into why the Department of Justice will not conduct an investigation into Governor Whitmer's decision to place COVID-19 infected patients in long-term care facilities.

On behalf of the thousands of mourning Michigan families, we are requesting you pursue answers to the following question in the course of your investigation:

Who made the final decision within the department to forgo an investigation?
What data or information did the Department acquire from the Governor of Michigan that exonerated her of any wrongdoing?
Was anyone within the Administration in contact with officials at DOJ concerning the Michigan inquiry?
Was anyone within the Executive Office of the President in contact with officials at DOJ concerning the Michigan inquiry?
We are requesting a formal, in-person briefing from your office on whether you choose to open an investigation into the Department of Justice's decision. We appreciate you and your department's dedication to oversight within the Department of Justice. We look forward to speaking with you and your staff on your decision.

Source